Opinion:Gujarat 8th 9th in Per Capita Rural Urban Monthly Exp (C)
Opinion:
Gujarat 8th 9th in Per Capita Rural Urban Monthly Exp (C)
July22, 2013
When Mohan Bhagwat wanted India to become a Super Power – RSS is
supporting Shame Power under Narendra Modi who is most Incompetent and
Moorkh.
Story of Gujarat is not of Agricultural Growth & Fastest Growing
Economy but ‘Declining Rankings in Per Capita Expenditure’ and this
doesn’t include 2012-13 drought year.
Industrial decline started in 2009-10. 2010-11 was zero growth year
factory sector in spite of Rs.31K crore capital expenditure.
(SER2012-13 P-51)
Therefore Vibrant Gujarat2011 and Vibrant Gujarat2013 were total
frauds. Over 50% of Gujarat GDP constitutes Chemicals and refineries
polluting Industries – rest accounts for Rs.45,000 crores Value
Additions or $10b for 60 million population is Pathetic.
http://mospi.nic.in/Mospi_New/upload/Energy_Statistics_2013.pdf
On page 26 of Energy Stats Gujarat subsidized RIL SEZ Export refinery
operating at 153% capacity – a kind of scam when India get no benefit.
Similarly on P-28 Gujarat Installed Capacity went up 44% or 6000 MW in
12 months to 2011-12 and has already installed 24,000 MW Convention
power though demand is stagnant at 8000MW due to declining Industry in
Gujarat – renewal energy is growing fast.
Narmada Canal system had completely failed.
With this data that matches with Hunger and Malnutrition also BJP is
ruling Very Poorly Performing states where few rich are rapidly
becoming richer and 99% of population is starving and malnutrition.
BJP managed Finances of Bihar has actually slipped in Urban and rural
growth, Gujarat ranks have lowered to 8th and 9th from 4th and 7th for
rural and Urban households.
BJP ruled MP, Bihar, Gujarat have poorly performed.
Ravinder Singh
Inventor & Consultant
Progressindia008@yahoo.com
‘We need a leader who can make India a superpower’
Patna: Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh chief Mohan Bhagwat on Sunday said
the country needs “ek nayak” (one leader), who not only performs but
also has the capacity to lead its diverse groups to fulfill the
cherished collective aim of making the country a “mahashakti”
(superpower). The reference was to Gujarat CM Narendra Modi, but he
said so without naming him.
Addressing a gathering of RSS rank-and-file, also attended by top
Bihar BJP leaders, Bhagwat said this “one leader” need not be
“sarvagun sampanna”
(possess all the qualities of a good leader), but should be capable of
leading the people whose ancient credo regarding “unified identity”
has been “unity in diversity” that accommodated even small groups of
invaders.
Bhagwat said India is plagued by extreme emotions of both hope and
despair with regard to its own emergence as “a successful emerging
economy or a superpower”. PTI
Gujarat slides in both rural, urban spending
Data Raises Doubt Over Devpt Model
Subodh Varma TIG
There’s a new trend of chief ministers, particularly those with
national ambitions, aggressively peddling their respective
‘development models’. Interestingly, CMs from the same party at times
indulge in one up man ship.
The question is: How are people in their states actually faring? How
does one know whether one ‘model’ is better than another?
One way is to look at how much a person spends on an average every
month; this gives an indication of how much people are earning.
Comparing recently released data on consumer expenditure with data
from a decade ago provides a fair idea of which state governments are
delivering and which are sliding. There’s a surprise lurking there.
Gujarat, the poster boy of development and economic growth, is one
of the few states that have slid in economic rankings.
Consumption expenditure of people in Gujarat is growing at a
slower rate than the national average, according to a comparative
analysis of data on monthly per capita spending between 2011-12 and
1999-2000, both of which are put out by the National Sample Survey
Organization (NSSO).
Gujarat has slid from fourth to eighth position in the ranking of
states for rural spends, and from seventh to ninth in urban
expenditure. The only other state showing a similar movement in
ranking — but moving up — is Andhra Pradesh.
Behind hype, development seems to stutter in Gujarat
Gujarat has slid from fourth to eighth position in the ranking of
states for rural spends, and from seventh to ninth in urban
expenditure. The only other state showing a similar movement in
ranking — but moving up — is Andhra Pradesh. It has dramatically
improved from 11th place in 2000 to fifth in 2012 in rural households
and from 11th to sixth in urban households. Another state that has
shown major movement in rankings is Tamil Nadu, moving down from
second to seventh place in urban per capita expenditure but improving
from sixth to fourth in rural.
Kerala, Punjab, Haryana, TN and AP are the top five states in
rural households; Haryana, Kerala, Maharashtra, Karnataka and Punjab
are the top five in urban households. The same reality is reflected in
growth rates of household expenditures over the period. At the
national level, average per person spends grew by 165% in rural areas
and 190% in urban areas between 2000 and 2012. Among the states with
MPCE growth of urban households lower than the national average,
Gujarat (177%) lies tied with Rajasthan, lower than Uttar Pradesh and
West Bengal but higher than Assam and TN.
Among rural households, per capita spend in Gujarat grew by 165%,
again below the national average of 170%. In Haryana too rural incomes
are barely above the national average. So, in terms of both absolute
levels of per capita spending as well as growth rates over the past 12
years, some of the more hyped-up states are not doing so well.
Gujarat 8th 9th in Per Capita Rural Urban Monthly Exp (C)
July22, 2013
When Mohan Bhagwat wanted India to become a Super Power – RSS is
supporting Shame Power under Narendra Modi who is most Incompetent and
Moorkh.
Story of Gujarat is not of Agricultural Growth & Fastest Growing
Economy but ‘Declining Rankings in Per Capita Expenditure’ and this
doesn’t include 2012-13 drought year.
Industrial decline started in 2009-10. 2010-11 was zero growth year
factory sector in spite of Rs.31K crore capital expenditure.
(SER2012-13 P-51)
Therefore Vibrant Gujarat2011 and Vibrant Gujarat2013 were total
frauds. Over 50% of Gujarat GDP constitutes Chemicals and refineries
polluting Industries – rest accounts for Rs.45,000 crores Value
Additions or $10b for 60 million population is Pathetic.
http://mospi.nic.in/Mospi_New/upload/Energy_Statistics_2013.pdf
On page 26 of Energy Stats Gujarat subsidized RIL SEZ Export refinery
operating at 153% capacity – a kind of scam when India get no benefit.
Similarly on P-28 Gujarat Installed Capacity went up 44% or 6000 MW in
12 months to 2011-12 and has already installed 24,000 MW Convention
power though demand is stagnant at 8000MW due to declining Industry in
Gujarat – renewal energy is growing fast.
Narmada Canal system had completely failed.
With this data that matches with Hunger and Malnutrition also BJP is
ruling Very Poorly Performing states where few rich are rapidly
becoming richer and 99% of population is starving and malnutrition.
BJP managed Finances of Bihar has actually slipped in Urban and rural
growth, Gujarat ranks have lowered to 8th and 9th from 4th and 7th for
rural and Urban households.
BJP ruled MP, Bihar, Gujarat have poorly performed.
Ravinder Singh
Inventor & Consultant
Progressindia008@yahoo.com
‘We need a leader who can make India a superpower’
Patna: Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh chief Mohan Bhagwat on Sunday said
the country needs “ek nayak” (one leader), who not only performs but
also has the capacity to lead its diverse groups to fulfill the
cherished collective aim of making the country a “mahashakti”
(superpower). The reference was to Gujarat CM Narendra Modi, but he
said so without naming him.
Addressing a gathering of RSS rank-and-file, also attended by top
Bihar BJP leaders, Bhagwat said this “one leader” need not be
“sarvagun sampanna”
(possess all the qualities of a good leader), but should be capable of
leading the people whose ancient credo regarding “unified identity”
has been “unity in diversity” that accommodated even small groups of
invaders.
Bhagwat said India is plagued by extreme emotions of both hope and
despair with regard to its own emergence as “a successful emerging
economy or a superpower”. PTI
Gujarat slides in both rural, urban spending
Data Raises Doubt Over Devpt Model
Subodh Varma TIG
There’s a new trend of chief ministers, particularly those with
national ambitions, aggressively peddling their respective
‘development models’. Interestingly, CMs from the same party at times
indulge in one up man ship.
The question is: How are people in their states actually faring? How
does one know whether one ‘model’ is better than another?
One way is to look at how much a person spends on an average every
month; this gives an indication of how much people are earning.
Comparing recently released data on consumer expenditure with data
from a decade ago provides a fair idea of which state governments are
delivering and which are sliding. There’s a surprise lurking there.
Gujarat, the poster boy of development and economic growth, is one
of the few states that have slid in economic rankings.
Consumption expenditure of people in Gujarat is growing at a
slower rate than the national average, according to a comparative
analysis of data on monthly per capita spending between 2011-12 and
1999-2000, both of which are put out by the National Sample Survey
Organization (NSSO).
Gujarat has slid from fourth to eighth position in the ranking of
states for rural spends, and from seventh to ninth in urban
expenditure. The only other state showing a similar movement in
ranking — but moving up — is Andhra Pradesh.
Behind hype, development seems to stutter in Gujarat
Gujarat has slid from fourth to eighth position in the ranking of
states for rural spends, and from seventh to ninth in urban
expenditure. The only other state showing a similar movement in
ranking — but moving up — is Andhra Pradesh. It has dramatically
improved from 11th place in 2000 to fifth in 2012 in rural households
and from 11th to sixth in urban households. Another state that has
shown major movement in rankings is Tamil Nadu, moving down from
second to seventh place in urban per capita expenditure but improving
from sixth to fourth in rural.
Kerala, Punjab, Haryana, TN and AP are the top five states in
rural households; Haryana, Kerala, Maharashtra, Karnataka and Punjab
are the top five in urban households. The same reality is reflected in
growth rates of household expenditures over the period. At the
national level, average per person spends grew by 165% in rural areas
and 190% in urban areas between 2000 and 2012. Among the states with
MPCE growth of urban households lower than the national average,
Gujarat (177%) lies tied with Rajasthan, lower than Uttar Pradesh and
West Bengal but higher than Assam and TN.
Among rural households, per capita spend in Gujarat grew by 165%,
again below the national average of 170%. In Haryana too rural incomes
are barely above the national average. So, in terms of both absolute
levels of per capita spending as well as growth rates over the past 12
years, some of the more hyped-up states are not doing so well.
Comments
Post a Comment